Skip to Content

Episode 29: The Matthew Monagle Horror-igin Story

Matthew Monagle Certified Forgotten

Matthew Monagle

Last week, we presented our listeners with a unique proposition: what if we turned the microphone back on ourselves and shared our own horror origin (horrorigin?) stories for a change? The result was the Matt Donato Origin Story, where Donato opened up about the experiences and friendships that helped shape his relationship to the genre.

This week it's Matthew Monagle's turn to share his story with our listeners. In our latest episode, Monagle shares his biggest childhood fear, the terrible fate of his My Buddy doll, and the winding path that led him from Alaska to Texas to New York, with plenty of twists and turns along the way.

And if you're in the mood for more personal commentary from Matthew, here are a few articles to check out:

"Her, Me, and the Movies: A Love Triangle" (Film School Rejects)
In this essay, Monagle shares the experience of falling in love with someone who could care less about your Letterboxd.

"You Should Probably Go To More Movies By Yourself" (Film School Rejects)
In his 20s, Monagle started going to see movies by himself at the movie theater. In this article, he shares how this made his relationship to the cinema better than ever.

"How the 'Alien' RPG Reignited My Love of the Franchise" (WhatToWatch)
In this article, Monagle shares how a childhood love of the Aliens franchise circled back in new and interesting ways in his 30s.

Want to learn even more about the founders of Certified Forgotten? Listen to the Matt Donato episode on Spotify or Apple Podcasts and check out the rest of our podcast episodes on our Podcasts page.

If you enjoyed this article, please share it on social media! Word of mouth is everything for independent publications likes ours.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Certified Forgotten

‘Camp’ Review: Avalon Fast’s Horror Feature Explores the Other Side of Trauma

Writer-director Avalon Fast explores what happens when a broken soul heals wrong in their fantastical summer horror film 'Camp.'

June 22, 2026

‘Pitfall’ Review: Even a Bad Outdoors Slasher Still Has Its Moments

James Kondelik's 'Pitfall' is a bit too rough around the edges to hit the mark, but it still knows how to play the redneck hits.

June 21, 2026

‘Misper’ Review: Harry Sherriff’s Debut Is a Beautiful Ghost Story for the Living

Harry Sherriff's 'Misper' may only be horror-adjacent, but it deserves to be celebrated as a tender examination of what follows trauma.

June 20, 2026

‘The Mid-Night Driver’ Review: The Right Mix of Nostalgia and Horror

Alex Cherney's 'The Mid-Night Driver' feels lifted from the pages of classic horror anthologies like 'Tales from the Crypt.'

June 20, 2026

‘Sender’ Review: Britt Lower Anchors a Relatably Mundane Nightmare

Russell Goldman's 'Sender' may be overwrought at times, but Britt Lower and the rest of the cast anchor this relatably mundane nightmare.

June 16, 2026

Podcast: ‘Backrooms’ Gets Uncertified

Certified Forgotten hosts Matt Donato and Matthew Monagle sit down to discuss Kane Parsons's 'Backrooms,' his breakout debut horror feature.

June 15, 2026
See all posts