Skip to Content

Episode 22: BJ Colangelo Stirs Up a ‘Teenage Cocktail’

Teenage Cocktail Nichole Bloom Fabianne Therese

Netflix

Here at Certified Forgotten, we've been known to cast a pretty wide net when it comes to the definition of horror. Not all films that deal with dread or terror fit neatly into the horror carousel on a Netflix page. Sometimes, some of the movies that hit the hardest are the ones that sidestep most genre conventions entirely.

READ MORE: 'The Hold in the Ground' Finds the Irish Horror in A24

One such film is John Carchietta's Teenage Cocktail, a 2016 thriller that explores what happens when a pair of high school lovers cross paths with a possessive fan who demonstrates the worst elements of toxic masculinity. For those who live their lives even semi-publically online, Teenage Cocktail is a far more frightening and realistic outcome than any number of movies about killers in the woods.

READ MORE: Exploitation and Empowerment in the Films of Sion Sono

In this new episode of Certified Forgotten, the Matts are joined by writer BJ Colangelo to discuss the ways in which Teenage Cocktail both subverts and uplifts the coming-of-age formula. The team also discusses how Teenage Cocktail avoids some of the more common mistakes with lesbian love stories.

You can rent Teenage Cocktail on Amazon or Apple TV. Check out the rest of our podcast episodes on our Podcasts page.

If you enjoyed this article, please share it on social media! Word of mouth is everything for independent publications likes ours.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Certified Forgotten

‘Hunting Matthew Nichols’ Review: A Solid Exercise in Docu-Horror

Markian Tarasiuk's 'Hunting Matthew Nichols' looks for inspiration in true crime documentaries - and it mostly works.

March 31, 2026

‘The Cremator’ Is a Meditation on Extremist Indoctrination

Tori Potenza explains why Juraj Herz's 'The Cremator' remains, sadly, as relevant today as it was a half-century ago.

March 23, 2026

‘1000 Women in Horror’ Review: A Much-Needed Refresh of Horror Canon

'1000 Women in Horror,' the new documentary from Donna Davies and Alexandra Heller-Nicholas, returns women to the heart of horror.

March 21, 2026

‘Ready or Not: Here I Come’ Review: Better Living Through Bloodshed

Everyone's favorite bad-luck bride is back in 'Ready or Not: Here I Come,' the bloodier and sillier sequel from Radio Silence.

March 20, 2026

‘Predators’ Wants Us To Maintain Our Empathy Amidst the Horrors

Lívia Reim explains why there's an important lesson in empathy for horror fans who seek out David Osit's 'Predators' documentary.

March 17, 2026

‘undertone’ Review: Even Great Sound Design Still Needs a Story

Ian Tuason's 'undertone' may be a masterclass in sound design, but it still fails to give us a story worth caring about.

March 12, 2026
See all posts