Skip to Content
Podcasts

Podcast: ‘I Know What You Did Last Summer’ With B.J. Colangelo

In this special edition of our Uncertified series, B.J. Colangelo and Matt Donato break down the new 'I Know What You Did Last Summer.'

I Know What You Did Last Summer

Sony Pictures Releasing

When only one-half of the Matts are available for a podcast, what do you do? Bring on one of the hardest-working critics in the industry to talk horror, that's what. In this special episode of Certified Forgotten's Uncertified series, Matt Donato is joined by B.J. Colangelo (This Ends at Prom) to discuss Jennifer Kaytin Robinson's modern take on an I Know What You Did Last Summer movie. And to paraphrase David Gordon Green: "Nostalgia dies tonight."

It's been 28 years since the events of Jim Gillespie's original film, but some mistakes are easily repeated. In the new film, a group of five friends take part in a terrible accident and choose to cover up their crimes. But when they start receiving mysterious messages that suggest someone is aware of what they partook in the previous July, the group turns to the survivors of a similar serial killer to learn how they might survive.

In this short except from the episode, Colangelo explains how the two films are in dialogue with each other, and how this creates strange parallels between the franchise bookends:

Each movie is the weird reflection of the other, because these characters are weird versions of each other set in different time periods. And a lot of their sensibilities change, because they're in different time periods. But that opens up a very interesting conversation about nostalgia, about giving people the exact same thing in a new coat of paint.

The I Know What You Did Last Summer episode of the Certified Forgotten podcast is now available to stream on SpotifyApple PodcastsYouTube Music, or the podcast platform of your choice.

If you enjoyed this article, please share it on social media! Word of mouth is everything for independent publications likes ours.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Certified Forgotten

Podcast: ‘Five Nights at Freddy’s 2’ Gets Uncertified (with BJ Colangelo)

Film critic BJ Colangelo joins Matt Donato to discuss 'Five Nights at Freddy's 2,' the latest adaptation of the popular video game series.

December 5, 2025

Will Letterboxd’s Video Store Be Good for Indie Horror?

Film distribution guru James Emanuel Shapiro explains why Letterboxd's Video Store strategy has good intentions but tough sledding ahead.

December 1, 2025

Podcast: Meredith Borders on ‘The Peanut Butter Solution’

Fangoria senior editor Meredith Borders returns to the podcast to talk about gateway horror cult classic 'The Peanut Butter Solution.'

November 29, 2025

‘Spiral’ Is a Warning That Bleeds Through the Screen

Christine Makepeace explains why Kurtis David Harder's 'Spiral' has only increased in urgency since its release.

November 24, 2025

Podcast: ‘Keeper’ Gets Uncertified

Matt Donato and Matthew Monagle break their recent Osgood Perkins ceasefire in this discussion of 'Keeper.'

November 21, 2025

‘Wildling’ Offers No Mercy for Weak-Minded Men

Molly Henery sheds no tears for the small-minded men of Fritz Böhm's 'Wildling' in this edition of her Uterus Horror series.

November 20, 2025
See all posts